IDOR Lab Report

Report on IDOR lab activity

IDOR Vulnerabilities

In this report, the OWASP Juice Shop webapp is used to showcase the exploitation of two IDOR vulnerabilities. Part of this document is based on material from prof. Alberto Bartoli.

Tools

  • OWASP Juice Shop (running from Docker image) v18.0.0
  • BURP Suite Proxy v2025.7.4

Challenge #1. View Basket

Description: View another user’s shopping basket

Of course, this is a mistake in the code of the webapp, i.e., a vulnerability: a user must not be able to see data private of another user.

Preliminary steps

  1. Create two accounts, e.g.:
    • a@gmail.com
    • b@gmail.com
  2. Login as a@gmail.com
  3. Add a product to the basket
  4. Visualize the content of the basket by clicking on the cart icon: basketa
  5. Logout and then login as the other user, i.e., b@gmail.com
  6. Add a product to the basket

Discovery

  1. Set Intercept On.
  2. Visualize the content of the basket by clicking on the cart icon. BURP will intercept, among others, a GET requests to the endpoint /rest/basket/7

basketrequest

Notice that, as requests are stalling, the content of the basket is not showing up.

  1. Set Intercept Off and make sure the shopping basket has been fully displayed. Under the hood, the client-side JavaScript has processed the server response and has dynamically updated the DOM to display the basket content. basketb
  2. Go to the HTTP History tab and inspect the response to the request GET /rest/basket/7. The resource in the body of the response is represented in JSON: 
    {
 "status":"success",
 "data":{
     "id":7,
     "coupon":null,
     "UserId":24,
     "createdAt":"2025-09-10T14:37:23.218Z",
     "updatedAt":"2025-09-10T14:37:23.218Z",
     "Products":[
         {
             "id":6,
             "name":"Banana Juice (1000ml)",
             "description":"Monkeys love it the most.",
             "price":1.99,
             "deluxePrice":1.99,
             "image":"banana_juice.jpg",
             "createdAt":"2025-09-10T14:05:01.949Z",
             "updatedAt":"2025-09-10T14:05:01.949Z",
             "deletedAt":null,
             "BasketItem":{
                 "ProductId":6,
                 "BasketId":7,
                 "id":10,
                 "quantity":1,
                 "createdAt":"2025-09-10T14:37:57.462Z",
                 "updatedAt":"2025-09-10T14:37:57.462Z"
             }
         }
     ]
 }
}

Observations:

The request GET /rest/basket/7 may be suggestive of an IDOR vulnerability: the parameter in the URL path represents a direct object reference, which identifies the shopping basket of this user.

The value of the parameter in the URL path (i.e., 7) is a small integer and, as such, it is enumerable and seems highly predictable. Security through obscurity is not implemented.

Ultimately, the presence of an IDOR vulnerability depends on whether the application enforces proper authorization checks.

The actual exploitation attempt procedure is outlined in the following:

  1. Go to the HTTP History tab and select the request GET /rest/basket/7.
  2. Right click on it and select Send to Repeater
  3. Move to the Repeater tab. Modify the request by incrementing or decrementing the url parameter.
  4. Click on send and check the response. alt text
  5. Note that the basket represented in JSON within the response is the one related to the user a@gmail.com, whereas the current user, who sent the request, is b@gmail.com.
  6. Check the browser. A vulnerability found banner will show up.

The web application is vulnerable to IDOR: due to missing authorization checks, a user can access the shopping basket of another user.

Exploiting in practice

Decrementing the parameter was just an educated guess (the account a@gmail.com was manually created few seconds before b@gmail.com).

In a practical setting the attacker would not know how many users are logged in and what their corresponding “small integer” values are. The attacker would thus have to repeatedly send GET /rest/basket/basket-id, with many different values for basket-id.

This procedure can be automated in BURP with the Intruder module, as follows.

  1. Go to the HTTP History tab and select the request GET /rest/basket/7 (as before, logged in as b@gmail.com)
  2. Right click on it and select Send to Intruder
  3. Move to the Intruder tab.
  4. Specify which part of the request has to be modified at each iteration: select the parameter value 7 in the request and click on Add §. The request will appear as follows: GET /rest/basket/§7§ alt text
  5. Specify how to modify the selected part of the URL at each iteration: in the Payloads tab set Payload Type: Numbers and set a reasonable range (e.g., Sequential from 1 to 10 with step 1).
  6. Specify which part of the response will be extracted and shown in the results window: on the side Menu on the right, click on the Settings tab; in the Grep - Extract section, click on Add. Selecting a portion of text in the response will create a suitable configuration automatically. Click Ok. alt text
  7. Click on Start attack.
  8. A window related to the attack will appear. The column “success” (the name derives from the ‘start from’ expression) shows the content of the extracted text for each response. Note that the payloads 8, 9, 10 probably do not represent valid values of basket-id, as the extracted value of data is null. In the bottom part of the window, each request and response can be inspected. alt text

Challenge #2. Manipulate Basket

Description: Put an additional product into another user’s shopping basket.

The preliminary steps of the previous challenge can be leveraged.

Discovery

  1. Set Intercept On.
  2. In the browser, add a product to the basket.
  3. BURP will intercept a GET /rest/basket/7. Forward it.
  4. BURP will then intercept, among others, a POST requests to the endpoint /api/BasketItems with the following body {"ProductId":42,"BasketId":"7","quantity":1} additem
  5. Set Intercept Off and make sure the shopping basket has been updated.

Observations:

The request POST /api/BasketItems may be suggestive of an IDOR vulnerability: the parameter BasketIdin the request body represents a direct object reference, which identifies the shopping basket to be updated, associated with the current user.

The actual exploitation attempt procedure is outlined in the following:

  1. Go to the HTTP History tab and select the request POST /api/BasketItems.
  2. Right click on it and select Send to Repeater
  3. Move to the Repeater tab. Modify the request as before (e.g., decrementing the id)
  4. Click on send and check the response.
  5. Note that the response code and status indicate 401 Unauthorized with body {'error': 'Invalid BasketId'} alt text

At a first glance, an authorization mechanism is in place. However, the presence of such a check does not necessarily mean that the authorization functionality is free of flaws: it may still be vulnerable to IDOR (and indeed it is, since this challenge exists). Further hints provided by the companion website may help identify where the authorization logic fails and how the vulnerability can be exploited.

Try to complete the challenge! Also report any uncessful attempt you find interesting.